Whether you are an African expatriate hoping to stay in touch with
what is going on in your home country, a potential tourist hoping to do
research on the best place to visit, a political student striving to
understand the development in Africa, or simply well-wisher dedicated to
unload of few bucks to chip in the aid for Africa, translating the
information you read into valuable knowledge is an important task
Like
any other continent, Africa offers a set of complex realities that can
offer conflicting outcome for the party interested; moreover, accessing
the information you need is not always evident between the information
you look for, and the information you find.
Below is a short
description of criteria to consider when reading or researching news on
Africa. While the list is not exclusive, and can certainly be extended, I
believe this initial guidepost may help. Feel free to add or consider
additional helpful points.
1. Consider the source of the information
Africa
is a very complex place, that combines many world and realities, the
gap between the rich and the poor creates in many places two different
societies whose world rarely collide. For that reason, news sources are
often tailored to one group or the other.
Understanding the source
of the information will help you assess the legitimacy of the
information you have. For example, is it a local or foreign news source?
Foreign sources often have greater access to political circles because
the government is more concerned about the way it is portrayed to the
outside world; however, foreign sources rarely give you the real pulse
of the nation. If the source is local, consider the accreditation that
is reflected by interviews or first hand accounts. In Africa, Official
news is often given unofficially, while official news is a front. That
means that those sources that have close access to the government are
more likely to give credible news, compare to unaccredited sources to
whom is given generic news. (More on it further down)
2. Try to capture the perspective of the information
In
Africa, the freedom of the press is not a sacred duty, and as mentioned
above, free and transparent news are not evident. As a result, news
often reflects the perspective of the source. The information you will
get is based on the perception of the source. In the West, Africa is
widely primarily viewed as a continent ravaged by war and diseases,
where impoverished people and government are struggling very hard to
survive, and thus their lives and activities are geared toward Help and
how the global community can help them. As a result, most African news
coming from the West will treat topics such as aid, sanction, peace and
war, and oil discovery. Human rights, rigged election and corruption are
other subjects often treated; in other words, Western media tend to
chronicle Africa's efforts to "join" or emulate them.
When it
comes to local media and news sources, the dilemma is different. Elite
and well positioned news sources depicts the political life of the
country, meaning that their news are mostly geared toward accounts of
big political activities, such as Presidential travels and visits,
opposition complaints, foreign investment, dignitaries visits, Diaspora
news and international events in which the government participate. In
short, those news sources attempts to present information from the
perception of Africa to the rest of the world.
Finally, local
media perception is often directed at the local population, therefore
offers information on issue that matters to locals; energy and gas
issues, employment, government promises kept or not, education,
political freedom, cultural and social safeguard, etc...
3. Acknowledge the Biases
In
the U.S, it is often assumed that CNN is Pro-democrats, and Fox News is
a Republican arm, regardless if true or not, that perception is very
present in Africa as well; not in form of Republican or democrats of
course, but they still play a short role.
From the day of
colonization, Western Nations had strategic interests in Africa, and
Political propaganda has insured that many Westerners view some African
countries internal policies as beneficial or threatening to their way of
life.
If your African news information is from a Western source,
always consider the position of your country with the African country
you are researching. Popular opinion is critical and very few Western
media will say nice things about the Zimbabwe government for example.
Western media will offer news based on the national interest of their
home country. You will rarely read negative report about the Egyptian
Government that has good relations with Washington, although it is not a
beacon of Democracy, yet Zimbabwe, which has been a torn in their side,
is demonized. This is not an attempt to justify the evil of some
people, but it is worth considering that Western media will report
information according to the way they wish a certain country to be
viewed.
If you wish to avoid the biases of Western news outlet,
you are better off searching for African news by African news outlets.
There again, there is an often bias between Pro and anti government.
Some news sources are government sponsored, while other are dedicated to
discredit the government regardless of good deeds or not. In Africa the
contrast is usually very strong, as you can read full articles of
"official" news feed that praises the government unashamedly, while
others are almost littered with insults. Very rarely will you find news
source that are impartial, and it is usually very evident to distinguish
the sources political leanings.
Given the polarity of African
societies, and the actuality of International Relations, one must not
look at news Biases with pure disgust, but as a component and vital
actor of global politics; filling between diverse biases can actually
help uncover valuable information. But in case it doesn't help, always
consider independent news and...
4. Identify the agendas
If
for some reasons you are unable to filter official and supposedly
professional news sources, do make use of independent news sources such
as NGO's and Think Tank. Because they are usually unaffiliated with any
government, and their work is mainly based on empirical data and
research, NGO and Think Tank do paint an educated and comprehensive
picture of what is going on in Africa. Most of their works are expanded
toward a wide range of subjects that reflects a non-partial view of
government activities, social realities and international implications.
If
you obtain your news via NGOs or Think Tanks, you are most likely to
have access to strong data, depending on the Think Tank, and hard core
evidence of what is going on in the country you research.
The only
problem presented by NGOs and Think Tanks is that they do have an
agenda. The nature of their strong work is usually motivated by the
mission to influence or advice a government to act toward an issue they
view as important. Because of that agenda, those organizations often
accentuate an issue to the point where it overshadows others, making it
look like an exaggeration.
For example if an NGO has for agenda to
reduce arm trafficking in Africa, their information may offer solid
leads on the pulse of a country, with credible evidence; however, their
extensive research on the impact of arm trafficking may minimize other
positive information, to the point of giving the impression that you can
buy Ak47 at a candy store. This of course is not with the intent to
deceive or dramatize, but with the objective of using the data to
convince world powers to act on arms trafficking.
If you know how to extract your information from those sources, they are an excellent balance to local and international news.
5. Check the blogs
Africa
sends millions of its bright Sons and Daughters abroad to study in
higher education, and loses other millions professionals in search of a
better living. While the damages of this brain drain are considerable,
the attachment all those Africans retain for their homeland represents a
glimpse of hope.
Since they cannot directly be involve in
official affairs in their home countries because of the distance or
political threats, many member of the African Diaspora voice their
opinions in blogs or personal websites.
The advantage of reading
those opinionated blogs is that it offers a personal touch and reaction
to all the other news you may have read.
Many are very
knowledgeable in what they are writing, and approach it in a very
professional way. They are not constrained by editorial control, so are
free to give their honest, educated opinion on what they read, heard or
experienced in and out of Africa.
If they are not that
knowledgeable on African affairs anymore, many still have families
abroad who can give them first account to report on what is happening.
Because
they are so many blogs related to Africa, you can not only compare
information and news, but also engage the writers and have a better feel
on how and where they get to say what they are saying.
For most
people, this is a valuable source, because on top of general political
views, they can offer a personal one, as well as giving an insight on
how and where people live their everyday, not to mention, where the
hotspots are.
The disadvantage of Blogs is that it is after all
just personal opinions, and personal opinions can be motivated or
inspired by perception, Bias, and /or agenda. It is not uncommon for
exile politicians to mount an opposition from abroad, something blogs
tend to make easier, so caution is advised for that reason.
6. Search for supportive news
Every news agency is in search of a scoop, and none wants to be left out of considerable information.
Whenever
you stumble on interesting information for your research, after
identifying the source, always make sure to search if that information
is reprised by other news outlets.
When it comes to Africa, it is
very common for news to be generalizing, but if you feel you came across
useful information, always double check if you can locate it in other
Western sources (if those where your primary sources), and then in local
African sources. Check in Blogs and social sites if it is being
discussed, or better create a new discussion.
The fact of the
matter is that if you are looking for information on Africa, the
complexity of its state does not favor taking any information at face
value, but insuring that it is shared, discussed and not hostage to any
perception and bias will help you have good grip on what is going on.
7. Use common sense
In
Politics like in everything, things happen for a reason, from a coup
d'Etat, to a social uprising, and political instability to international
sanction.
Africa is not another planet we know nothing about, and it did not appear without a past or history.
In
everything you read or learn about Africa, consider the context and
remember history. Famine and poverty did not come suddenly; wars all
have a spark plug, poor countries should not be able to buy weapons they
do not manufacture.
The context and the historical reality that
today links nearly all countries on Earth presents the fertile ground on
how you will receive the news you receive, they way you receive it.
Knowledge
is a light to which is drawn a bug called interest, and common sense
should help you navigate the waves of misinformation toward the land of
comprehension of the subject you research.
As mentioned, this is a
list that can be extended and perfected, but for all who have at one
point or another, read African news or wanted to understand what is
going in Africa, I hope that little list will be helpful the next time
it happens.
No comments:
Post a Comment